Audiobooks Like Things We Never Got Over

10 audiobooks for fans of Things We Never Got Over

1. 1

   

   By a Thread

   by Lucy Score

   Narrated by Erin Mallon, Sebastian York

   ★ 4.36 BLT Score (183.0K ratings)

   ★ 4.07 Goodreads (179.2K) ★ 4.62 Audible (3.7K)

   14h 21m listening time • Released 2020

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
2. 2

   

   Mistakes Were Made

   Story Lake • Book 2

   by Lucy Score

   Narrated by Lila Winters, Sebastian York

   ★ 4.30 BLT Score (1.9K ratings)

   ★ 4.46 Goodreads (1.6K) ★ 4.81 Audible (291)

   17h 32m listening time • Released 2026

   Winters and York crackle with chemistry in this small-town romance, their banter so sharp and perfectly timed it feels like eavesdropping on real people falling for all the wrong reasons.

   More about this pick

   Winters and York crackle with chemistry in this small-town romance, their banter so sharp and perfectly timed it feels like eavesdropping on real people falling for all the wrong reasons.

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
3. 3

   

   Rock Bottom Girl: A Small Town Romantic Comedy

   by Lucy Score

   Narrated by Natalie Duke, Stephen Dexter

   ★ 4.32 BLT Score (1.5K ratings)

   ★ 4.64 Audible (1.5K)

   14h 53m listening time • Released 2019

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
4. 4

   

   Forever Never

   by Lucy Score

   Narrated by Ramona Master

   ★ 3.94 BLT Score (99.4K ratings)

   ★ 3.96 Goodreads (98.3K) ★ 4.28 Audible (1.1K)

   17h 3m listening time • Released 2021

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
5. 5

   

   Across the Vanishing Sky

   Starlight Grove • Book 1

   by Catherine Cowles

   Narrated by Jason Clarke, Samantha Brentmoor, Sebastian York, Adam Gold, Teddy Hamilton, Connor Crais

   ★ 4.56 BLT Score (10.8K ratings)

   ★ 4.54 Goodreads (10.3K) ★ 4.85 Audible (564)

   13h 51m listening time • Released 2026

   The ensemble cast—Clarke, York, Brentmoor leading the charge—transforms this dark mystery into something gripping and layered. Multiple narrators handling a complex past makes the twists land harder.

   More about this pick

   The ensemble cast—Clarke, York, Brentmoor leading the charge—transforms this dark mystery into something gripping and layered. Multiple narrators handling a complex past makes the twists land harder.

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
6. 6

   

   The Miles High Club Series 4 Books Collection Box Set By T L Swan (The Stopover, The Takeover, The Casanova & The Do-Over)

   The Miles High Club • Book 1

   by T.L. Swan

   Narrated by Sebastian York, CJ Bloom

   ★ 4.24 BLT Score (9.2K ratings)

   ★ 4.57 Goodreads (286) ★ 4.54 Audible (8.9K)

   12h 58m listening time • Released 2019

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
7. 7

   

   The Ex I'd Love to Hate

   The Lasker Brothers • Book 3

   by Nadia Lee

   Narrated by Sebastian York, Maxine Mitchell

   ★ 4.28 BLT Score (10.4K ratings)

   ★ 4.11 Goodreads (10.0K) ★ 4.78 Audible (383)

   15h 13m listening time • Released 2023

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
8. 8

   

   Under Locke

   by Mariana Zapata

   Narrated by Ava Erickson, Bradley Ford, Sebastian York

   ★ 4.03 BLT Score (103.8K ratings)

   ★ 3.88 Goodreads (103.4K) ★ 4.47 Audible (406)

   15h 38m listening time • Released 2024

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
9. 9

   

   The Boyfriend Effect

   Frisky Business • Book 1

   by Kendall Ryan

   Narrated by Jacob Morgan, Andi Arndt, Vanessa Edwin, Sebastian York, Erin Mallon

   ★ 3.91 BLT Score (7.0K ratings)

   ★ 3.65 Goodreads (6.9K) ★ 4.63 Audible (177)

   15h 55m listening time • Released 2023

   Start Listening → Get the Book →
   Start Listening → Get the Book →
10. 10

    

    The Last Letter

    by Rebecca Yarros

    Narrated by Teddy Hamilton, Jennifer Stark

    ★ 4.78 BLT Score (552.4K ratings)

    ★ 4.49 Goodreads (538.1K) ★ 4.75 Audible (14.3K)

    13h 23m listening time • Released 2019

    Hamilton and Stark's dual narration captures the raw grief and unspoken tension between these characters with such precision that you'll feel the weight of every unsaid word. This is emotional fiction that demands to be heard.

    More about this pick

    Hamilton and Stark's dual narration captures the raw grief and unspoken tension between these characters with such precision that you'll feel the weight of every unsaid word. This is emotional fiction that demands to be heard.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
    Start Listening → Get the Book →