Books Like The Thirteenth Tale

Read more

Bianca Amato and Jill Tanner split Diane Setterfield's gothic two-hander with voices that feel genuinely separate — Amato's biographer warm but probing, Tanner's aging author guarded and theatrical in a way that keeps the mystery alive across 16 atmospheric hours. The list reaches toward the same layered unease, with several award-winning picks and highly rated titles that share the novel's appetite for secrets told at a careful remove.

10 books for fans of The Thirteenth Tale

  1. 1
    Sunrise on the Reaping cover

    Sunrise on the Reaping

    The Hunger Games

    by Suzanne Collins

    More about this pick

    Follow teenage Haymitch Abernathy into the arena during the second Quarter Quell, where the Capitol's twisted anniversary celebration doubles the death toll.

    4.50 Goodreads (1.1M ratings)
  2. 2
    My Friends cover

    My Friends

    by Fredrik Backman

    More about this pick

    Four teenagers forge a friendship so powerful it reaches across twenty-five years to transform a complete stranger's life in ways none of them could imagine.

    4.36 Goodreads (413.4K ratings)
  3. 3
    The Buffalo Hunter Hunter cover

    The Buffalo Hunter Hunter

    by Stephen Graham Jones

    More about this pick

    Jones crafts horror from the historical slaughter of buffalo and the hunters who killed them. Violence echoes across time in this supernatural tale of ecological and cultural revenge.

    3.99 Goodreads (47.6K ratings)
  4. 4
    Saving Fish from Drowning cover

    Saving Fish from Drowning

    by Amy Tan

    3.47 Goodreads (33.2K ratings)
  5. 5
    Theo of Golden cover

    Theo of Golden

    by Allen Levi

    More about this pick

    When Theo starts purchasing ninety-two portraits from a coffeehouse wall, he quietly begins changing an entire town through simple acts of recognition.

    4.57 Goodreads (168.5K ratings)
  6. 6
    The Correspondent cover

    The Correspondent

    by Virginia Evans

    More about this pick

    An epistolary novel built from discovered correspondence reveals one woman's journey through decades of artistic ambition, romantic heartbreak, and historical upheaval. Evans explores how letters create intimate connections across time and preserve the fragments that define a life.

    4.53 Goodreads (364.9K ratings)
  7. 7
    The Great Alone cover

    The Great Alone

    by Kristin Hannah

    Why this book?

    Both novels weave atmospheric storytelling with deeply personal mysteries that unfold gradually, drawing listeners into richly layered narratives where family secrets and hidden truths drive the plot forward. Julia Whelan's immersive narration captures the same haunting, character-driven tension that makes *The Thirteenth Tale* so compelling, while the Alaskan wilderness setting provides a similarly gothic and isolating backdrop for psychological drama.

    4.46 Goodreads (1.2M ratings)
  8. 8
    Arch of Triumph cover

    Arch of Triumph

    by Erich Maria Remarque

    4.43 Goodreads (32.8K ratings)
  9. 9
    The Godfather cover

    The Godfather

    The Godfather • Book 1

    by Mario Puzo

    Why this book?

    The Godfather's intricate plot layering and exploration of family secrets mirrors the gothic mystery and narrative complexity of The Thirteenth Tale, while Joe Mantegna's commanding narration delivers the same immersive, character-driven listening experience across an equally substantial runtime.

    4.40 Goodreads (468.0K ratings)
  10. 10
    Remarkably Bright Creatures cover

    Remarkably Bright Creatures

    by Shelby Van Pelt

    More about this pick

    What starts as a widow's late-night cleaning job at an aquarium becomes something unexpectedly profound when she connects with a giant Pacific octopus who might hold clues to her son's disappearance.

    4.36 Goodreads (1.3M ratings)