Between You & Me

A medical emergency in the quiet heart of Amish country sets this emotionally charged story in motion. Caleb Stoltz has made a solemn promise to raise his orphaned niece and nephew within the traditions of Middle Grove, where life revolves around faith, family, and farm. When a crisis pulls him into the world of high-tech medicine, he collides with Dr. Reese Powell, an ambitious physician from a high-achieving family. What begins as a clash of values escalates into a courtroom confrontation that tests the limits of law, love, and deeply held belief.

The dual narration by Tanya Eby and Adam Verner brings the story's central tension to life in ways print cannot replicate. Eby captures Reese's sharp, driven energy, while Verner lends Caleb a quiet gravity that makes his internal conflict feel earned. At nearly eleven hours, the pacing mirrors the novel's rhythm: deliberate in quieter moments, urgent when stakes rise. Susan Wiggs's emotionally layered prose translates naturally to audio, and the contrast between two distinct voices reinforces the cultural divide at the story's core.