Every Summer After cover

Every Summer After

Barry’s Bay • Book 1

by Carley Fortune

4.17 Goodreads
(884.1K ratings)

Why You'll Love This

A decade of silence, one phone call, and suddenly Percy is back at the lake where she ruined everything.

  • Great if you want: a dual-timeline romance where the past slowly explains the present
  • The experience: nostalgic and aching — cozy summer mood with a quiet devastation underneath
  • The writing: Fortune writes longing with unusual restraint — no melodrama, just accumulating ache
  • Skip if: you find 'one that got away' premises predictable

About This Book

Some losses don't announce themselves until years later, when you're standing in a place you swore you'd never return to, face-to-face with the person you walked away from. That's exactly where Persephone Fraser finds herself in Carley Fortune's debut novel — back at the lakeside town where she spent six transformative summers and made one decision she can't undo. The novel moves between past and present, tracing a friendship that slowly became something more and a rupture that split a life in two. The emotional stakes aren't explosive or dramatic; they're the quiet, aching kind — the loss of belonging, of someone who knew you before you became whoever you are now.

Fortune's real skill is in the dual timeline, which she handles with unusual confidence for a debut. The past sections carry genuine warmth and specificity — summer light on water, borrowed books, the rhythms of a small community — while the present unfolds with the tight, held-breath tension of someone trying to understand a choice they've never fully forgiven themselves for. The prose is unhurried and sensory without being overwrought, and the pacing earns its emotional payoff rather than rushing toward it.