Mistakes Were Made cover

Mistakes Were Made

Story Lake • Book 2

by Lucy Score

4.46 Goodreads
(1.6K ratings)

Why You'll Love This

A woman allergic to commitment accidentally moves in with a man who has his wedding already planned — and neither of them sees it coming.

  • Great if you want: enemies-to-lovers tension with real romantic stakes and big laughs
  • The experience: fast, funny, and addictive — a breezy 600 pages that doesn't feel long
  • The writing: Score's banter crackles; she writes comic timing like a screenwriter
  • Skip if: you prefer understated romance — Score leans into big, broad emotion

About This Book

What happens when the most commitment-phobic woman in Manhattan gets stranded in small-town Pennsylvania with no money, no plan, and a landlord who's actively shopping for a wife? Lucy Score turns that collision into something far more layered than a simple opposites-attract setup. Zoey Moody is sharp, self-aware, and genuinely funny about her own chaos — but beneath the bravado is a woman whose professional identity has collapsed and whose personal life is held together with sarcasm and avoidance. Gage Bishop is equally complicated: steady and intentional without being boring. The tension between them isn't just romantic friction; it's a genuine clash of two people who both want things they're afraid to admit.

Score writes with a pace and warmth that make 600-plus pages feel earned rather than indulgent. The Story Lake setting breathes without overwhelming the story, and the supporting cast — particularly Hazel — adds texture rather than distraction. What sets this book apart on the page is Score's skill with interior voice: Zoey's perspective is consistently entertaining while slowly, almost sneakily, becoming vulnerable. Readers who appreciate romantic comedy with actual emotional consequence will find the length completely justified.