The Wrong Sister cover

The Wrong Sister

by Claire Douglas

Narrated by Eleanor Tomlinson

4.27 ABR Score (56.0K ratings)
★ 3.93 Goodreads (54.1K) ★ 4.51 Audible (1.8K)
8h 55m Released 2025 Thriller

Why Listen to This Audiobook?

Eleanor Tomlinson makes both sisters sound completely trustworthy — which is exactly the problem.

  • Great if you want: domestic suspense where family bonds become the threat
  • Listening experience: compact and tense — under 9 hours, no wasted scenes
  • Narration: Tomlinson subtly shifts each sister's voice to keep suspicion alive
  • Skip if: you've grown tired of twist-heavy domestic thriller formulas

Listen to The Wrong Sister on Audible →

About This Audiobook

When Tasha accepts her globe-trotting sister Alice's offer to house-sit and watch the children, she anticipates a peaceful getaway with her husband. Instead, she returns to devastating news: Alice lies in intensive care while her husband Kyle is dead, victims of a brutal attack in Tasha's own home. The police investigation takes a chilling turn when Tasha receives an anonymous message suggesting she was the intended target. As the sisters' seemingly close relationship unravels under scrutiny, long-buried family secrets surface, forcing Tasha to question everything she thought she knew about Alice and their shared past.

Eleanor Tomlinson delivers a masterful performance that captures the psychological tension threading through Douglas's thriller. Her nuanced portrayal distinguishes between the two sisters while maintaining the story's mounting sense of unease and paranoia. Tomlinson's pacing allows listeners to absorb each revelation naturally, building suspense without rushing the emotional beats that make the family dynamics so compelling. The audio format proves ideal for this intimate psychological study, as Tomlinson's expressive delivery transforms internal monologue and dialogue into an immersive experience that keeps listeners questioning motives until the final moments.