Best Whodunit Books

The highest-rated books featuring whodunit, ranked by readers. Browse 50 titles across Mystery, Thriller, Fantasy.

Read more

Whodunits are built on a fundamental appeal: the promise that all the pieces are there, hidden in plain sight, waiting for you to connect them. There's genuine pleasure in being misled, in suspecting the wrong person, in that moment when a seemingly throwaway detail suddenly becomes the lynchpin of the whole puzzle. You're not just following a story—you're competing against it, trying to solve the mystery before the final pages reveal who did it. The tension comes from knowing a crime happened and watching the investigator (and you) narrow down possibilities, each interview or clue shifting the odds.

You'll find whodunits across mystery and thriller shelves, from cozy village murders to high-stakes heists, from classic parlor mysteries to contemporary locked-room puzzles. What unites them is the central architecture: a crime, multiple suspects with motive and opportunity, and a detective methodically—or chaotically—working toward the truth. Some offer fair-play puzzles where you genuinely could solve it first; others prioritize momentum and psychological suspense. Either way, expect misdirection, red herrings, and that addictive compulsion to flip ahead just one more chapter to see if you were right.

These are the highest-rated whodunit books across Mystery, Thriller, Fantasy, ranked by reader ratings from Goodreads and Audible.

  1. 1
    Sherlock Holmes: The Definitive Collection cover

    Sherlock Holmes: The Definitive Collection

    Sherlock Holmes • Book 1

    by Arthur Conan Doyle, Stephen Fry - introductions

    4.51 Goodreads (217.9K ratings)
  2. 2
    The complete Sherlock Holmes cover

    The complete Sherlock Holmes

    Sherlock Holmes #1-9

    by Arthur Conan Doyle

    More about this pick

    The definitive collection of detective fiction follows Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson through four novels and fifty-six short stories of deductive brilliance. Doyle created the template for analytical detection that every mystery writer since has built upon.

    4.51 Goodreads (217.8K ratings)
  3. 3
    O homem que morreu duas vezes cover

    O homem que morreu duas vezes

    Thursday Murder Club • Book 2

    by Richard Osman, Jaime Biaggio

    More about this pick

    Elizabeth and her fellow retirement home detectives encounter stolen diamonds, Cold War espionage, and a corpse that seems to have died twice. Osman's second mystery deepens his characters while delivering another perfectly plotted puzzle filled with wit and unexpected twists.

    4.35 Goodreads (360.6K ratings)
  4. 4
    And Then There Were None cover

    And Then There Were None

    by Agatha Christie

    More about this pick

    Christie's isolated island setting becomes a pressure cooker where ten guests with hidden secrets are systematically eliminated according to a chilling children's rhyme.

    4.27 Goodreads (1.6M ratings)
  5. 5
    Payback in Death cover

    Payback in Death

    In Death • Book 57

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    A retired Internal Affairs captain's staged suicide exposes decades of police corruption as Dallas investigates enemies within her own department's history.

    4.46 Goodreads (26.0K ratings)
  6. 6
    Survivor in Death cover

    Survivor in Death

    In Death • Book 20

    by J.D. Robb, Nora Roberts

    More about this pick

    Robb crafts her most emotionally complex case as Eve Dallas adopts a young witness to a family massacre, balancing her investigation with unexpected maternal instincts in 2059 New York.

    4.42 Goodreads (35.7K ratings)
  7. 7
    The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo cover

    The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

    Millennium Series • Book 1

    by Stieg Larsson

    More about this pick

    Mikael Blomkvist investigates a forty-year-old disappearance while hacker Lisbeth Salander uncovers corporate corruption. Larsson weaves financial intrigue with brutal family secrets in this Swedish thriller masterpiece.

    4.18 Goodreads (3.5M ratings)
  8. 8
    Thud! cover

    Thud!

    Discworld • Book 34

    by Terry Pratchett

    More about this pick

    Commander Vimes has days to solve a dwarf's murder before ancient ethnic hatred between trolls and dwarfs reignites in the streets of his city.

    4.36 Goodreads (79.8K ratings)
  9. 9
    Encore in Death cover

    Encore in Death

    In Death • Book 56

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Broadway and Hollywood power couple's charity gala turns fatal when the host dies from cyanide poisoning, exposing decades of entertainment industry rivalries.

    4.40 Goodreads (25.9K ratings)
  10. 10
    Feet of Clay cover

    Feet of Clay

    Discworld • Book 19

    by Terry Pratchett

    More about this pick

    Commander Vimes faces his most complex case yet as someone poisons the city's elderly elite while golems begin thinking for themselves. Pratchett examines free will, class consciousness, and social revolution through his signature blend of mystery plotting and satirical wit.

    4.33 Goodreads (93.9K ratings)
  11. 11
    Born in Death cover

    Born in Death

    In Death • Book 23

    by J.D. Robb, Nora Roberts

    More about this pick

    Eve Dallas investigates when two employees of a prestigious accounting firm are killed on the same night, while helping organize a baby shower for Mavis. Robb balances murder mystery with friendship and future parenthood themes.

    4.38 Goodreads (32.2K ratings)
  12. 12
    The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (Agatha Christie - HINDI Book 1) (Hindi Edition) cover

    The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (Agatha Christie - HINDI Book 1) (Hindi Edition)

    Hercule Poirot • Book 4

    by Agatha Christie

    More about this pick

    Roger Ackroyd discovers who was blackmailing the woman he loved, then gets murdered before he can act—Christie's most shocking plot twist awaits.

    4.26 Goodreads (354.0K ratings)
  13. 13
    Divided in Death cover

    Divided in Death

    In Death • Book 18

    by J.D. Robb, Nora Roberts

    More about this pick

    Former Secret Service agent Reva had every reason to kill her artist husband and her best friend when she discovered their affair, but Eve Dallas believes someone else orchestrated the perfect frame job.

    4.36 Goodreads (33.0K ratings)
  14. 14
    Indulgence in Death cover

    Indulgence in Death

    In Death • Book 31

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Wealthy killers turn murder into entertainment, hunting victims with crossbows and antique weapons for the ultimate rush. Robb exposes how extreme privilege can corrupt into monstrous indifference toward human life.

    4.36 Goodreads (30.9K ratings)
  15. 15
    Murder on the Orient Express cover

    Murder on the Orient Express

    A Hercule Poirot Mystery • Book 10

    by Agatha Christie

    More about this pick

    Trapped by snow on a luxury train, Poirot investigates a murder where every passenger has an alibi and the victim had enemies everywhere.

    4.20 Goodreads (741.3K ratings)
  16. 16
    Seduction in Death cover

    Seduction in Death

    In Death • Book 13

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Candlelit dinners, rose petals, expensive wine—and a rare drug that kills within hours, leaving Dallas to decode whether she's hunting a romantic or a predator.

    4.35 Goodreads (33.7K ratings)
  17. 17
    The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes cover

    The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes

    Sherlock Holmes • Book 4

    by Arthur Conan Doyle

    More about this pick

    This collection showcases Holmes at his analytical peak, tackling cases that range from seemingly impossible murders to elaborate schemes spanning decades. Conan Doyle demonstrates why the detective's methods became legendary.

    4.29 Goodreads (106.3K ratings)
  18. 18
    Witness in Death cover

    Witness in Death

    In Death • Book 10

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Broadway's leading man dies from a real knife during the climactic death scene—Eve Dallas must solve a murder performed for a theater full of witnesses.

    4.33 Goodreads (37.8K ratings)
  19. 19
    Celebrity in Death cover

    Celebrity in Death

    In Death • Book 34

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Robb explores the strange intersection of reality and fiction as Dallas investigates a murder at a party celebrating a movie based on her own cases—where the victim was playing her.

    4.33 Goodreads (30.2K ratings)
  20. 20
    Strangers in Death cover

    Strangers in Death

    In Death • Book 26

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Robb constructs an intricate puzzle around a wealthy man's death, where the killer's careful staging might be too perfect and the grieving widow too composed.

    4.33 Goodreads (30.1K ratings)
  21. 21
    Concealed in Death cover

    Concealed in Death

    In Death • Book 38

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Demolition of an abandoned building reveals the skeletons of twelve teenagers, sending Dallas into the past to solve murders that someone is still killing to keep buried. Robb's 38th installment proves that some secrets refuse to stay hidden.

    4.33 Goodreads (27.5K ratings)
  22. 22
    Festive in Death cover

    Festive in Death

    In Death • Book 39

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Eve investigates a personal trainer's murder while navigating her first Christmas as a billionaire's wife. Holiday stress meets homicide as scorned lovers line up as suspects.

    4.33 Goodreads (27.0K ratings)
  23. 23
    Secrets in Death cover

    Secrets in Death

    In Death • Book 45

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Robb turns a gossip columnist's murder into an exploration of how information becomes currency and secrets become weapons in 2060s New York. Dallas uncovers a blackmail network hidden behind Manhattan's glittering social scene.

    4.33 Goodreads (25.9K ratings)
  24. 24
    Calculated in Death cover

    Calculated in Death

    In Death • Book 36

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    Lieutenant Eve Dallas sees past the obvious when beloved accountant Marta Dickenson dies in what appears to be a robbery gone wrong on the Upper East Side.

    4.30 Goodreads (28.6K ratings)
  25. 25
    Salvation in Death cover

    Salvation in Death

    In Death • Book 27

    by J.D. Robb

    More about this pick

    When Father Miguel Flores drops dead after drinking communion wine laced with cyanide, Lieutenant Eve Dallas discovers the victim wasn't who he claimed to be.

    4.29 Goodreads (28.2K ratings)
  26. 26
    Trunk Music cover

    Trunk Music

    Harry Bosch • Book 5

    by Michael Connelly

    More about this pick

    Bosch's first case back from suspension: a Hollywood producer executed mob-style, but the LAPD's organized crime unit wants him to stay away.

    4.22 Goodreads (78.0K ratings)
  27. 27
    A Study in Scarlet cover

    A Study in Scarlet

    Sherlock Holmes • Book 1

    by Arthur Conan Doyle

    More about this pick

    Holmes and Watson's initial meeting launches into a murder investigation spanning London and the Mormon frontier. Conan Doyle's origin story shows how the legendary partnership began.

    4.13 Goodreads (499.1K ratings)
  28. 28
    Junkyard Dogs cover

    Junkyard Dogs

    Walt Longmire • Book 6

    by Craig Johnson

    More about this pick

    Multi-million dollar developers want to eliminate the adjacent junkyard, but when a severed thumb appears among the scrap metal, Sheriff Longmire faces escalating violence.

    4.26 Goodreads (21.0K ratings)
  29. 29
    Death on the Nile (Poirot) cover

    Death on the Nile (Poirot)

    Hercule Poirot • Book 18

    by Agatha Christie

    More about this pick

    Poirot investigates when a wealthy heiress dies on her honeymoon cruise, with every passenger harboring motives for murder.

    4.12 Goodreads (310.9K ratings)
  30. 30
    Cold Blood cover

    Cold Blood

    Detective Erika Foster • Book 5

    by Robert Bryndza

    More about this pick

    Bryndza's fifth Erika Foster mystery connects a dismembered body in a suitcase to an earlier brutal murder, showcasing his talent for visceral crime fiction.

    4.25 Goodreads (18.4K ratings)
  31. 31
    Death Without Company cover

    Death Without Company

    Walt Longmire • Book 2

    by Craig Johnson

    More about this pick

    Sheriff Walt Longmire faces a poisoning case that dredges up old secrets in small-town Wyoming, testing his investigative skills and personal relationships.

    4.22 Goodreads (28.3K ratings)
  32. 32
    The Ink Black Heart cover

    The Ink Black Heart

    Cormoran Strike • Book 6

    by Robert Galbraith

    More about this pick

    Edie Ledwell created a beloved webcomic, but online trolls have turned her life into hell—and now someone wants her dead. Galbraith's longest Strike novel yet dives deep into internet culture, examining how anonymous harassment can escalate to real-world violence.

    4.13 Goodreads (118.0K ratings)
  33. 33
    Where Shadows Dance cover

    Where Shadows Dance

    Sebastian St. Cyr • Book 6

    by C.S. Harris

    More about this pick

    How do you investigate a murder no one can admit occurred? Sebastian St. Cyr confronts this puzzle when a illegally-obtained corpse reveals a Foreign Office star's suspicious death in 1812 London.

    4.26 Goodreads (9.4K ratings)
  34. 34
    Where Serpents Sleep cover

    Where Serpents Sleep

    Sebastian St. Cyr • Book 4

    by C.S. Harris

    More about this pick

    Harris uses the brutal slaughter of eight young women to explore 1812 London's social reform movements and political corruption. Hero Jarvis proves as compelling an investigator as St. Cyr himself.

    4.25 Goodreads (10.4K ratings)
  35. 35
    The 9th Judgment cover

    The 9th Judgment

    Women's Murder Club • Book 9

    by James Patterson, Maxine Paetro

    More about this pick

    Two shocking attacks on families push the Women's Murder Club to their limits as they race to stop a killer targeting parents with a cryptic message written in blood.

    4.15 Goodreads (60.8K ratings)
  36. 36
    Where the Dead Lie cover

    Where the Dead Lie

    Sebastian St. Cyr • Book 12

    by C.S. Harris

    More about this pick

    Sebastian St. Cyr investigates the brutal murder of a 15-year-old street child in 1813 London, racing to find the boy's missing sister before she meets the same horrific fate.

    4.29 Goodreads (5.8K ratings)
  37. 37
    Sycamore Row cover

    Sycamore Row

    Jake Brigance • Book 2

    by John Grisham

    More about this pick

    Grisham brings back Jake Brigance to defend a handwritten will leaving millions to a black maid, igniting racial tensions in a case that threatens to destroy his career and family.

    4.10 Goodreads (141.1K ratings)
  38. 38
    What Remains of Heaven cover

    What Remains of Heaven

    Sebastian St. Cyr • Book 5

    by C.S. Harris

    More about this pick

    London's reform-minded Bishop lies bludgeoned in a crypt beside another victim killed decades earlier—Sebastian St. Cyr must unravel connections spanning generations.

    4.24 Goodreads (9.6K ratings)
  39. 39
    The Silent Girl cover

    The Silent Girl

    Rizzoli & Isles • Book 9

    by Tess Gerritsen

    More about this pick

    Detective Jane Rizzoli finds a woman's severed hand in a Chinatown alley and her nearly decapitated body on the tenement roof above, launching a case that will haunt her dreams.

    4.15 Goodreads (46.4K ratings)
  40. 40
    Why Kings Confess cover

    Why Kings Confess

    Sebastian St. Cyr • Book 9

    by C.S. Harris

    More about this pick

    Sebastian St. Cyr's investigation of a murdered French doctor in London's slums uncovers a decades-old mystery that threatens his pregnant wife Hero.

    4.26 Goodreads (7.2K ratings)
  41. 41
    The Heavens May Fall cover

    The Heavens May Fall

    Detective Max Rupert • Book 3

    by Allen Eskens

    More about this pick

    Best friends turned legal adversaries clash when detective Max Rupert arrests the man attorney Boady Sanden must defend — both convinced they're right about the same murder.

    4.19 Goodreads (20.1K ratings)
  42. 42
    When Maidens Mourn cover

    When Maidens Mourn

    Sebastian St. Cyr • Book 7

    by C.S. Harris

    More about this pick

    Sebastian investigates when Hero's friend, an antiquarian studying Arthurian legends, is found dead at the site she claimed was Camelot.

    4.24 Goodreads (8.8K ratings)
  43. 43
    The Silkworm cover

    The Silkworm

    Cormoran Strike • Book 2

    by Robert Galbraith, J.K. Rowling

    More about this pick

    Strike searches for novelist Owen Quine, whose new book savagely parodies real people with murderous detail—then Quine turns up dead, killed exactly like in his manuscript. Galbraith crafts a locked-room mystery within the vindictive world of literary publishing.

    4.05 Goodreads (296.4K ratings)
  44. 44
    15th Affair cover

    15th Affair

    Women's Murder Club • Book 15

    by James Patterson, Maxine Paetro

    More about this pick

    A dead man in a luxury hotel room pulls detective Lindsay Boxer into a case that could destroy everything she's built—her marriage, career, and life.

    4.14 Goodreads (44.2K ratings)
  45. 45
    25 Alive (WMC #25): A Women's Murder Club Thriller cover

    25 Alive (WMC #25): A Women's Murder Club Thriller

    Women's Murder Club • Book 25

    by James Patterson, Maxine Paetro

    More about this pick

    Detective Lindsay Boxer and her crime-solving partners tackle the shocking murder of a former police chief in San Francisco's Golden Gate Park. This twenty-fifth series entry promises familiar characters and Bay Area settings.

    4.16 Goodreads (29.0K ratings)
  46. 46
    The Valentine Cipher: A Homefront Sleuths Mystery (The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series Book 8) cover

    The Valentine Cipher: A Homefront Sleuths Mystery (The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series Book 8)

    Homefront Sleuths • Book 8

    by Anna Elliott, Charles Veley

    More about this pick

    Valentine's Day wedding preparations turn deadly when the village curate is murdered days before seven couples plan to wed. Elliott and Veley blend wartime tension with cozy village mystery as Harry investigates with a famous secret guest about to arrive.

    4.53 Goodreads (1.1K ratings)
  47. 47
    The Likeness cover

    The Likeness

    Dublin Murder Squad • Book 2

    by Tana French

    More about this pick

    When Cassie finds a corpse bearing her face and fake ID, she must go undercover as the dead woman to infiltrate a group of graduate students living like it's still the 1920s.

    4.06 Goodreads (181.9K ratings)
  48. 48
    The Works of Edgar Allan Poe, Volume II (Edgar Allan Poe Classics Collection) cover

    The Works of Edgar Allan Poe, Volume II (Edgar Allan Poe Classics Collection)

    The Edgar Allan Poe Collection • Book 2

    by Edgar Allan Poe

    More about this pick

    Dupin's analytical mind solves impossible crimes while Poe explores the thin line between reason and madness through tales that defined both detective fiction and psychological horror.

    4.34 Goodreads (2.6K ratings)
  49. 49
    The Mysterious Affair at Styles cover

    The Mysterious Affair at Styles

    A Hercule Poirot Mystery • Book 1

    by Agatha Christie

    More about this pick

    Christie's debut novel introduces Hercule Poirot investigating a poison murder at an English country house. The case that launched a thousand mysteries establishes all the classic whodunit conventions.

    4.00 Goodreads (514.2K ratings)
  50. 50
    [The Murder at the Vicarage] [by: Agatha Christie] cover

    [The Murder at the Vicarage] [by: Agatha Christie]

    Miss Marple • Book 1

    by Agatha Christie

    More about this pick

    Miss Marple's debut case involves the murder of the most hated man in St. Mary Mead, where everyone had motive to kill Colonel Protheroe. Christie establishes her genius for making the obvious suspect innocent and the innocent suspect obvious.

    4.04 Goodreads (216.7K ratings)